Your correct, if this doesnt come off, im getting a new barrel. Tired of folks saying they dont care about rust and scratches, "its a tool" exactly, You wouldnt buy a "new" hammer with rust, I wouddnt buy a new pick up truck with rust. Same applies to my firearms I work too hard to get something thats rusted out the box? Im aware of normal wear and tear, got plenty of guns with wear. But to me as a consumer its not acceptable. Like I said before, If I cant get the rust out, I will send it off for them to try and get it off, or as "they" stated they would send a barrel if they couldnt. This was offered to me I didnt demand a barrel, I "informed" them as I thik everyone should.